Featured Story

Universal Orlando Resort: Where to Stay & Play for a Few Days

By

My recent stay at Universal Orlando Resort was so much fun and I’m going to share and highlight my favorite moments with you. First and foremost, I stayed at the Cabana Bay Beach Resort on the property which allowed me early access (one hour) to The Wizarding World of Harry Potter™. It was my first time experiencing Diagon Alley™. I took advantage of the complimentary shuttle service to Universal Studios Florida and was able to … [Read More...]

Life & Style

Navigating Disney World During a Pandemic

By

I recently had an opportunity to visit Walt Disney World as part of my Goofy Getaways FAM Training. It was exciting and I was a bit anxious because even though some restrictions are being lifted, guidelines are more relaxed, and travel is starting to … [Read More...]

Strike a pose at Pose Selfie Studio

By

I recently had an opportunity to visit the NEW Pose Selfie Studio in Raleigh, NC with my daughter and it was so much fun. The great thing about this studio is that you have all the tools you need to capture your perfect photos alone or you can go … [Read More...]

Taste the Flavors of St. Thomas USVI

By

I am excited to be collaborating with my fellow foodie lover Hannah Victoria on this listing of places to eat in St. Thomas USVI whether you are visiting or local to the island. We are giving you our personal opinions based on our dining experiences … [Read More...]

More Top Stories

Tech

Travel

Navigating Disney World During a Pandemic

By

I recently had an opportunity to visit Walt Disney World as part of my Goofy Getaways FAM Training. It was exciting and I was a bit anxious because even though some restrictions are being lifted, guidelines are more relaxed, and travel is starting to … [Read More...]

Taste the Flavors of St. Thomas USVI

By

I am excited to be collaborating with my fellow foodie lover Hannah Victoria on this listing of places to eat in St. Thomas USVI whether you are visiting or local to the island. We are giving you our personal opinions based on our dining experiences … [Read More...]

Food

Rosé All Day at Seasons 52

By

I recently had the opportunity to experience the Seasons 52 Summer Menu paired perfectly with Rose cocktails. The menu changes with the season and I can really appreciate that. My reservation was for 7:00pm and it … [Read More...]

Snorkeling in St. John Rental Gear Versus My Own Kit

St. John sits quietly in the US Virgin Islands, a short ferry ride from the cruise ships and the busier hum of St. Thomas. I had booked a week in a hillside villa with a view that pulled the eye straight down to the sea, and the only question was whether I would be strapping on a rental mask at the dock or unfolding my own familiar gear on a beach towel.

As someone who grew up chasing tides around Sydney's harbour beaches and later learned the rhythms of the Great Barrier Reef, I have strong opinions about what a good snorkel set should feel like. A leaky mask can ruin a session faster than choppy water, and fins that flap off your heels will send you chasing them across the surface. When the trip planning started, the gear debate turned into a real back-and-forth between my husband and me. He was firmly in the rent-on-arrival camp, and I was clinging to the idea of packing my own kit.

By the time we landed on St. John, we had compromised on a small experiment. I would rent for two days, then dig my own gear out of my suitcase for two more. Same bays, similar conditions, similar moods. The goal was simply to figure out which option deserved space in my bag the next time I booked a beach holiday.

The reef called and I had to answer

St. John is one of those islands where the underwater scenery feels like the main event. Trunk Bay has an underwater snorkel trail marked with plaques, Honeymoon Beach offers calm water for relaxed floating, and even the small bays near Cruz Bay hold patches of sea grass where stingrays cruise. Coming from Australia, where the Gold Coast and Byron Bay are known more for surf than for reef, the accessibility of Caribbean reef life felt like a real treat.

Within a minute of stepping off the sand at many of these beaches, I was drifting over elkhorn coral and spotting sergeant majors. The clarity of the water made even modest patches of reef feel like something out of a documentary. I lost track of time more than once while hovering over a single brain coral mound. It was the kind of reef experience that reminds you why people book flights to small islands in the first place.

Why renting looked like the easy win

The case for renting started at the airport. Australian carriers charge extra for every checked bag, and a mask, snorkel, and pair of fins can easily eat up half a suitcase that could otherwise hold souvenirs or sunscreen. Renting at a beach shop felt lighter in every sense. There was no stress about a mask cracking in transit, no rinsing ritual in the hotel sink the night before a swim, and no hauling a wet bag back home through customs.

There is also a certain freedom to walking into a shop on Cruz Bay and asking for a small mask, a dry-top snorkel, and medium fins, then walking out two minutes later with everything fitted and bagged. It feels much the same as hiring a surfboard at Manly for the day instead of bringing your own shortboard from home. You trade a bit of personality for convenience, and for a traveller who values light packing above almost everything else, the rental path is genuinely tempting.

Why bringing my own still had appeal

My own kit, by contrast, had followed me through reef trips off Cairns, lazy afternoons at Coogee, and a few too many laps around my sister's pool in Brisbane. It knew my face. The silicone skirt had molded itself to the shape around my nose and cheeks, which meant fewer leaks and less fiddling once I was in the water. The fins had soft, adjustable straps that did not bite into my arches, and the snorkel had a splash guard that actually worked.

Beyond fit, there is a hygiene question that sits in the back of every snorkeler's mind. Rental masks go on dozens of faces in a week, and shops do rinse them, but the silicone is rarely sterilised the way a personal mask is cared for at home. Bringing my own meant I was the only person breathing through that mouthpiece. For a traveller who already brings her own thongs to barbecues rather than wearing the pair stacked by the back door, it was a familiar kind of peace of mind.

The rental gear in real life

On the first morning, I walked into a small shop a block from the ferry dock and asked for the basics. The staff member handed me a clear silicone mask with a tempered glass lens, a basic J-snorkel, and a pair of black fins. The total for two days was reasonable. The mask sealed well enough once I pressed it firmly against my forehead and pulled the strap into place, and the fins were stiffer than mine but did the job.

The downsides showed up in the details. The snorkel did not have a dry valve at the top, so every wave that washed over me sent a small fountain down the tube. The fin straps were the older buckle style, which I had to tighten every few minutes because the rubber loosened in the warm water. The staff were friendly and happy to swap sizes, but there was a slight assembly-line feeling to the whole transaction.

My own gear in the water

When I switched to my own kit two days later, the difference was immediate. The mask sat flush the moment it touched my skin, and I could drop my face in without a single adjustment. The dry-top snorkel kept out the splashes that had been sneaking past the rental one. The fins flexed with each kick instead of fighting me, which meant I used less energy and could hover longer over a patch of brain coral without drifting off course.

There was one small annoyance that came with familiarity. My mask still fogged up after a few minutes in the warm shallows, and a quick spit and rinse fixed it. The bigger comfort was psychological. I trusted my mask to seal, I trusted my fins to stay on, and I trusted my snorkel to breathe cleanly. That trust let me focus on a hawksbill turtle that paddled past me near a rocky outcrop.

Small comforts that tipped the scale

By the end of the week, the small things had stacked up. Rental gear is designed to fit the broadest range of faces and feet, which means it usually fits no one perfectly. My own gear is shaped to me, and that shape had been improved over years of fiddling, swapping straps, and replacing silicone parts. Australian beach culture has a similar respect for personal kit, whether it is a beloved pair of board shorts, a well-worn rashie, or a wetsuit that finally fits the way it should.

A snorkel is not quite the same as a longboard, but the principle holds. The mask that has been adjusted to your face, the fins that match your kick, and the snorkel that matches your breathing rhythm will always outperform a generic replacement. Comfort in the water is rarely about a single feature. It is the sum of all the small things that stop bothering you once your face is down, and that is where my own kit quietly won the week.

What the week taught me about future trips

Looking back, the rental-versus-own question is really a question about how you travel. If you fly with a budget carrier, dislike hauling gear, and only plan a couple of casual swims, rental on St. John works just fine. If you care about fit and hygiene, pack your own. The shops on the island are well stocked and the staff are patient, so neither choice will ruin a holiday.

I ended up doing both, and I will probably do the same trick again next time. The reef does not care which mask you wear, but your face does. You can read more about my travel experiments and gear notes over at JenOni, where I keep a running journal of the trips that teach me something useful.