Featured Story

Universal Orlando Resort: Where to Stay & Play for a Few Days

By

My recent stay at Universal Orlando Resort was so much fun and I’m going to share and highlight my favorite moments with you. First and foremost, I stayed at the Cabana Bay Beach Resort on the property which allowed me early access (one hour) to The Wizarding World of Harry Potter™. It was my first time experiencing Diagon Alley™. I took advantage of the complimentary shuttle service to Universal Studios Florida and was able to … [Read More...]

Life & Style

Navigating Disney World During a Pandemic

By

I recently had an opportunity to visit Walt Disney World as part of my Goofy Getaways FAM Training. It was exciting and I was a bit anxious because even though some restrictions are being lifted, guidelines are more relaxed, and travel is starting to … [Read More...]

Strike a pose at Pose Selfie Studio

By

I recently had an opportunity to visit the NEW Pose Selfie Studio in Raleigh, NC with my daughter and it was so much fun. The great thing about this studio is that you have all the tools you need to capture your perfect photos alone or you can go … [Read More...]

Taste the Flavors of St. Thomas USVI

By

I am excited to be collaborating with my fellow foodie lover Hannah Victoria on this listing of places to eat in St. Thomas USVI whether you are visiting or local to the island. We are giving you our personal opinions based on our dining experiences … [Read More...]

More Top Stories

Tech

Travel

Navigating Disney World During a Pandemic

By

I recently had an opportunity to visit Walt Disney World as part of my Goofy Getaways FAM Training. It was exciting and I was a bit anxious because even though some restrictions are being lifted, guidelines are more relaxed, and travel is starting to … [Read More...]

Taste the Flavors of St. Thomas USVI

By

I am excited to be collaborating with my fellow foodie lover Hannah Victoria on this listing of places to eat in St. Thomas USVI whether you are visiting or local to the island. We are giving you our personal opinions based on our dining experiences … [Read More...]

Food

Rosé All Day at Seasons 52

By

I recently had the opportunity to experience the Seasons 52 Summer Menu paired perfectly with Rose cocktails. The menu changes with the season and I can really appreciate that. My reservation was for 7:00pm and it … [Read More...]

Fresh fish and a St. Croix kitchen

My clearest memory of buying fresh fish from the dock in St. Croix is the smell of ice, diesel and sea air before the shops had opened. I had expected beaches and camera stops during my visit to the US Virgin Islands, but the early fishing scene gave me something more useful: a whole fish bought directly from the people who caught it. The meal felt connected to the island instead of merely bought for dinner.

The plan was deliberately simple: choose a fish, have it cleaned, learn how island cooks treat it, then cook it myself in a rental kitchen. I had eaten plenty of restaurant meals around St. Croix, but wanted the experience to begin at the water rather than on a printed menu. Freshness was only one part of the equation; timing, clean handling and restrained seasoning would decide whether the fish was genuinely good.

Early morning at the dock

I left Christiansted while the streets were quiet, following the sound of engines and ice being tipped into bins. By the working waterfront and fishing pier, several small boats sat close together and early customers leaned over coolers. St. Croix uses US dollars, and I had the exchange rate on my phone, but the transaction felt straightforward: point at a fish, agree on the price, and wait while it was prepared.

Before the visit, I checked the practical details I usually keep with my JenOni travel stories, including what to pack and how far the drive to the waterfront would be. The dock was busiest before breakfast, not lunch, and the light was already strengthening. St. Croix drives on the left even though many vehicles have steering wheels on the left, so that first drive felt unusually busy.

Choosing a fish worth cooking

At the unloading area, I was offered snapper, yellowtail, wahoo, tuna and several smaller reef fish. Availability changed with the boats and the season, so I did not arrive expecting a particular species. I chose a whole mahi-mahi, also known as dolphinfish, because it was firm, brightly coloured and looked recently caught. Its eyes were clear, its gills were red beneath the lid, and the seller kept it buried in ice.

I asked where it had been caught and whether it was troll-caught or line-caught, then requested scaling and gutting while keeping the head and tail on. The people handling the fish knew the local fishing grounds far better than I did, and their answers were more useful than anything on a generic seafood chart. I also checked local health advice before buying reef fish because ciguatera poisoning cannot be fixed by cooking; on this trip, mahi-mahi was the safer choice.

Back in Australia, I am used to counters displaying barramundi, snapper and kingfish, with labels such as line-caught or day boat. At the St. Croix dock, that information came through conversation and observation. I looked for intact skin, firm flesh, clean-smelling gills and constant contact with ice, then paid in US dollars rather than by the kilogram as I would at an Australian fishmonger.

From the dock to the rental kitchen

Once the fish was cleaned, the vendor packed it in a bag with crushed ice. I put it straight into the rental fridge and kept the door shut while I unpacked the groceries. Back home in Australia, supermarkets such as Woolworths and Coles normally sell fish filleted and measured in kilograms; a whole 1.5-kilogram mahi-mahi was a different proposition. It offered more usable flesh, but it also came with the job of breaking it down.

St. Croix shops sold plantains, limes, coconut, peppers and local produce with the same easy confidence as the fish. I bought what I needed for a simple barbecue and added rice and peas, the island pairing I had noticed on many menus. The kitchen was basic, with a two-burner hob and an outdoor grill, but that was enough. I rinsed the fish, patted it dry, seasoned it and let it rest while the charcoal warmed.

Cooking the fish my way

I rubbed the mahi-mahi with salt, garlic, lime juice and a little oil, then added a small amount of West Indian thyme and finely choppedScotch bonnet. The citrus sharpened the sweet fish without covering its flavour, while the heat stayed gentle enough to notice rather than dominate. I had watched island cooks season boldly, but restraint let me taste the difference between the fish I had bought and a generic supermarket fillet.

The main challenge was keeping the flesh moist over the barbecue. I oiled the hot grate, placed the fish skin-side down first and turned it only once. The skin crisped while the flesh stayed tender, and I checked the thickest part until it reached 63°C. Cooking times varied with the fish’s size and the strength of the charcoal, so colour alone was not a reliable guide.

Dinner came with the rice and peas, fried plantain and a cabbage-and-lime salad I made while the fish rested. The meal was generous without being elaborate. More importantly, the mahi-mahi tasted fresh and distinctly of the morning catch rather than fish that had spent too long in storage.

Comparing the dock with an Australian fish counter

Back in Australia, the closest comparison was a supermarket or fishmonger counter, especially at the Sydney Fish Market or Melbourne’s Queen Victoria Market. Australian counters make buying by weight easy, and labels such as line-caught or day boat help shoppers choose. A dock purchase felt less standardised: the fish was whole, advice was personal and the price depended on size and what the morning boats had landed.

The differences are useful if you are used to buying a pink salmon fillet for a frying pan. Whole fish can provide a similar amount of usable flesh once it is cleaned, while the bones and head create more work. Fish counters are quicker; dock fish can offer a stronger connection to the catch and a fresher meal if the handling has been properly done.

Point of difference Buying at a St. Croix dock Fish counter in Australia
Format Whole fish, usually cleaned on request Fillets, steaks or boneless portions
Price Quoted in US dollars for the selected fish Usually fixed in AUD per kilogram
Freshness clues Firm flesh, clear eyes and constant contact with ice Chilled display, catch details and packing dates
Preparation Scaling, gutting, filleting and bone removal remain your job Already trimmed and ready to cook
Best advantage A direct connection to the fisherman and the catch Convenience, consistent portions and easy comparison

Lessons for an Australian fisho

A fisho will understand the excitement of buying according to the morning catch rather than a fixed supermarket promotion. The most useful lesson was to slow down and ask questions before choosing. A quick conversation could reveal the species, fishing method and whether the seller had handled the catch properly.

At the dock, I would:

At an Australian counter, seafood naming can differ between states, so I would still ask the fisho what species is actually on the board. Barramundi, snapper and bream may not mean quite the same thing to every seller. I would also check the packing date, ask whether the fish was line-caught or day boat, and compare the price per kilogram rather than relying on a large promotion sign.

The strongest flavour came not from a complicated sauce but from a fish that had been chosen carefully, handled quickly and cooked without fuss. That meal remains one of the clearest tastes of St. Croix: cold morning air, a whole mahi-mahi, lime and thyme, and the satisfaction of cooking a fresh catch myself.